30 Aug Other Losses: An Investigation into the Mass Deaths of German Prisoners of War after World War Two by James Bacque Macdonald, pp. 30 Aug In , a little-known Canadian novelist, James Bacque, published Other Losses, alleging that “,, almost certainly over , and. 17 Apr much controversy among scholars and other interested readers. And yet, James Bacque keeps ferreting out more information that makes his.
|Published (Last):||13 August 2007|
|PDF File Size:||3.44 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||18.26 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Eisenhower was not a Hitler, he did not run death camps, German prisoners did not die by the hundreds of thousands, lsses was a severe food shortage inthere was james bacque other losses sinister or secret about the “disarmed enemy forces” designation or about the column “other losses.
Perhaps he can try the interviewing techniques that he employed in Other Losses llsses putting words in the mouths of selective eyewitnesses. Lists with This Book.
Then their American clothes and guns were taken from them, and their treatment as POWs went from honourable to disgraceful. Private Franz says that the Americans “were really shitty”.
As we celebrated the victory of our James bacque other losses tediously written badly organized and repetitious–and looks like it was padded out for publication –but the story it tells is appalling. Want to Read Currently Reading Read. While harsh treatment of prisoners occurred, no evidence exists that it was part of an organized systematic effort.
F.H. Hinsley reviews ‘Other Losses’ by James Bacque · LRB 30 August
Log In Register for Online Access. Paperbackpages. Eisenhower’s calculations as to how many people he would james bacque other losses required to feed in occupied Germany in were too low and he had been asking for more food shipments badque February How could the bodies disappear without one soldier’s coming forward in nearly fifty years to relieve his conscience? Other Losses states that Eisenhower sought to sidestep the requirements of the Geneva James bacque other losses through the designation of these prisoners as Disarmed Enemy Forces DEFspecifically stating that “in March, as Germany was being cracked Ilyas Ozturk rated it liked it Dec 09, Bischoff said that while “most scholarly reviewers of Bacque’s book have pointed out that Bacque fails to othed the james bacque other losses historical context”, “worse, the historical records that Bacque did use are amateurishly misrepresented and often misleading or wrong.
This is supported by a US Army document lodged in the US National Archives which “plainly states” that the “Other Losses” category lossse prisoners was for deaths and escapes.
Villa also states that Bacque’s assertion that the British rejected designations to not comply with the GC requirements are entirely unfounded jaames ignore that the British themselves requested that they be permitted to use such designations, with that request being granted by the CCS and used in surrenders to British troops.
That the highest officers ordered lower officers not to supply shelter in the camps, although tents were readily available? To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
Other Losses by James Bacque
That a james bacque other losses was able to hide and still continues to deny the savage treatment of James bacque other losses soldiers and civilians after winning WWII is a horrendous example of baacque much power placed into the hands of willful and devious men.
Mar 30, Greta marked it as not-to-read. The historian Niall Ferguson claims a significantly lower death rate of 0. The book claims that a “Missing Million” prisoners exist in the difference in totals between two Losess. The title of ” Other Losses ” derives from the heading of a column in weekly reports of the U.
» Other Losses One-Hour Documentary Film on DVD
Preview — Other Losses by James Bacque. What if the unchecked decline bacqye western civilization continues to the point james bacque other losses bel “Whoever controls the press proclaims that it is free. Other Losses lossses that james bacque other losses of thousands of German prisoners that had fled the Eastern front were designated as ” Disarmed Enemy Forces ” in order to avoid recognition under the Third Geneva Conventionfor the purpose of carrying out their deaths through disease or slow starvation.
Cowdrey stated that Bacque’s methodology for determining just the “Other Losses” figures was also “slipshod”, with Bacque filling gaps in the records where james bacque other losses “other losses” were recorded by “comput[ing] the number of deaths by applying the death rate given in Army statistics for another otyer to the known number of prisoners at hand.
Stephen Ambrosea historian Eisenhower had enlisted in his efforts to preserve his legacy and counteract criticisms of his james bacque other losses, and seven other historians examined jmaes book soon after its publication, and came to the conclusion that it was inaccurate and the product of conspiracy theory.
Not even Field Marshal Montgomery.
I think Mr Hinsley will find himself lonely in the belief that the James bacque other losses and Canadian Armies were so much better organised than the Americans that they signally succeeded where the Americans lossrs failed. Michael rated it really liked it May 31, This is the key point of Bacque’s book.
Other Losses One-Hour Documentary Film on DVD
Numerous reviews of the book written by the top talent in the military history profession such as Losaes Keegan and Russel Weigley were persuaded by the findings of the book.
Read this amazing book! Regarding prisoners in French custody, losss Rudiger Overmans states that, while the total number of prisoners dying in French custody might james bacque other losses exceeded the official statistic of 21, no evidence exists that it was hundreds of thousands of deaths higher than that figure, as Bacque claims.